RETAIL & ONLINE

Black Friday Marketing Without the Race to the Bottom

9 Minute Read

Black Friday marketing without the race to the bottom means building a plan around real preparation, honest pricing and a genuine reason to buy, rather than chasing the deepest discount on the high street or the loudest voice in a crowded inbox. A small business can win real sales from the day without training its customers to wait for the lowest price of the year and without breaking the rules that govern how "was" and "now" prices can be shown. This guide covers what UK shoppers spent and planned this year, the pricing law most retailers never read, and the practical steps that make Black Friday a day that builds the business rather than draining its margin.

A shop owner preparing an honest Black Friday display in their window

How Big Is Black Friday for UK Shoppers This Year?

Black Friday is still a genuinely large moment in the UK retail calendar, even as its edges soften. Barclays research found that shoppers were expected to spend an average of £430 each over the Black Friday period, £91 more than the year before, taking total spending past £10.2 billion across the UK. Nationwide's own payments data backs up the scale of it on the day itself. Black Friday on 28 November 2025 produced a record 11.9 million transactions, 8.7% higher than the 10.9 million transactions recorded on Black Friday the year before. That is a lot of people deciding to spend money on one Friday.

But the picture is not uniformly rising everywhere you look. The Office for National Statistics recorded seasonally adjusted retail sales volumes falling by 0.1% over the month, suggesting the Black Friday effect on the wider economy was slightly weaker than usual this year. Online retail told a steadier story. Online sales rose 0.7% month on month and were 8.3% higher than November the year before, which matters if your business sells through a website or a marketplace rather than a physical till. Finder's consumer research puts a number on individual intent too, finding that the average person planned to spend £124 across Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2025. Read together, these figures describe a shopper who is still showing up, still spending, and a little more selective about where.

Shoppers carrying bags along a UK high street during the Black Friday weekend

Why Chasing the Deepest Discount Costs You More Than It Wins

The instinct every November is to go deeper than last year's discount, on the theory that the steepest price wins the sale. This is where most small businesses lose money they never needed to lose. The research on how brands grow points in a different direction entirely. The Ehrenberg-Bass method's law of growth holds that brands grow by gaining more buyers, known as penetration, not by pushing existing loyal customers into buying more. Growth comes from reaching new people who were not already shopping with you, not from squeezing a bit more spend out of the ones who were coming anyway.

Heavy discounting does the opposite of what most owners think it does. A customer who was already going to buy from you in December now buys in November at a lower price, and you have given away margin on a sale you would have had regardless. Worse, every year you run a steeper discount than the last, you teach your most loyal customers that your full price is not your real price, and they learn to wait for the sale rather than buy when they need what you sell. A discount that only pulls forward existing demand is not growth. It is a loan against your own margin, repaid with interest in customer expectations the following year.

The alternative is to point your Black Friday effort at reaching people who do not already know you, through wider advertising reach, a referral push, or a presence in places your current customers already spend time, and to treat the discount itself as one part of a reason to buy rather than the whole of it. A smaller, well-reasoned offer paired with genuine visibility among new buyers tends to build the business in a way that the steepest possible markdown never does.

A small business owner reviewing stock left over after heavy discounting

What UK Pricing Law Says About "Was" and "Now" Prices

Before you set any Black Friday price, it helps to know what the rules say, because a surprising number of common Black Friday habits sit on the wrong side of consumer law. Reference pricing is the technical term for comparing your current price to another price, whether that is the RRP, a competitor's price, or your own previous price shown as a "was" figure against a "now" figure, and UK guidance is explicit that this kind of comparison carries legal weight, not a marketing flourish.

The practice that gets small retailers into trouble most often is the serial discount, where each new markdown does not offer a bigger saving than the last. Guidance from the Chartered Trading Standards Institute's Business Companion service gives a concrete example of exactly this problem: a coat offered at "was £150 now £99," then marked down again and advertised as "was £150, was £99, now half price £75". On paper that looks like an escalating bargain. In practice the first reduction already told the full story, and restating an old "was" price alongside a new one can mislead a shopper about how much they are saving. If your Black Friday plan involves a string of "was" prices stacked on top of each other, this is the exact pattern to check against before you publish anything.

The fix is straightforward. Keep your reference prices honest, make sure any "was" price reflects a price you genuinely charged for a reasonable period, and resist the temptation to layer discount on top of discount purely for dramatic effect. A single, clear, truthful saving does more for trust than a confusing stack of claims, and it keeps you well clear of a pricing complaint arriving in your inbox the week after Black Friday.

A shop assistant carefully writing an honest price label

How to Price Your Black Friday Offer Without Racing to the Bottom

Pricing a Black Friday offer well is less about finding the lowest number you can survive and more about finding the number that signals genuine value without cheapening what you sell every other week of the year. This is where the psychology of how people read a price matters as much as the arithmetic behind it. Our guide to psychological pricing goes deeper on the mechanics, but a few principles carry directly into Black Friday planning.

Frame the offer around a clear, single reduction rather than a maze of overlapping deals, since a shopper comparing five "up to" percentages across your site cannot tell which one applies to the thing they want. Bundle rather than blanket-discount where you can, because adding a genuine extra to the purchase often reads as more generous than shaving a further few pounds off the headline price, and it protects your margin on the core product. And hold a line on your very best-selling lines. Discounting the product that already sells itself gives away margin for no extra demand, while a meaningful reduction on something slower-moving can shift stock that was going to sit there regardless. None of this needs the deepest discount in your market. It needs the clearest one, priced, properly explained.

A maker setting prices on handmade products before a sale

How to Prepare a Black Friday Plan That Does Not Rely on Panic

The businesses that avoid the race to the bottom are, almost without exception, the ones that started planning months before the day itself rather than scrambling the week before. Waiting until November to decide what you are discounting, who you are telling, and how you will fulfil a sudden spike in orders is how a business ends up matching a competitor's price out of fear rather than judgement. Our full walkthrough on how to prepare for Black Friday covers the operational groundwork in detail, from stock and fulfilment to the content you need ready before the traffic arrives.

The short version is that preparation buys you the calm to price well rather than desperately. Decide your offer and your reasoning for it early enough that you are not reacting to what everyone else is doing in the final fortnight. Warm up your audience before the day with genuine previews rather than a surprise blast, since a customer who has been told what is coming is far more likely to act the moment it lands than one meeting the offer cold in a crowded inbox. And build in the capacity, whether that is stock, staff hours, or a website that can handle a surge, to deliver on the promise you make, because a Black Friday sale that ends in late deliveries or out-of-stock messages does more damage to trust than no sale at all.

A business owner planning their Black Friday campaign weeks in advance

What a Black Friday Campaign Built on Value Looks Like in Practice

To make this concrete, picture an illustrative small homeware shop called Thistle & Pine, a two-person business selling handmade ceramics online and from a small shopfront. Rather than matching the 50% off banners filling every larger retailer's site, Thistle & Pine offered a genuine, single discount on its best-loved mug range, priced against what it had charged for months beforehand, and paired it with a free hand-written care card for every order placed that weekend. The offer was simple enough to explain in one sentence, which meant it travelled well in a short social post and an email that did not need three paragraphs of small print to be understood.

In the weeks before, Thistle & Pine told its existing customers the offer was coming and used a modest amount of advertising reach to introduce the shop to people who had never bought from it, rather than spending the whole budget re-selling to people already on the list. The result, as this hypothetical illustrates, is the shape every small business should be aiming for: a clear, honest saving that respects the rules on reference pricing, reaching some genuinely new customers alongside the loyal ones, without a single price slashed so far that it undercut the brand's own sense of what its work is worth.

Two small business owners packing orders during a Black Friday sale

How Do You Measure Whether Black Friday Worked?

The day after Black Friday is when most small businesses only look at one number: how much did we take. That answer is useful, but it is not the whole story, and treating it as the only measure is how a business ends up chasing a bigger discount every year regardless of whether the discount itself was the reason people bought. The ONS found that around 3 in 10 adults (31%) planned to shop in the Black Friday sales this year, with 19% intending to shop less than the year before and 10% intending to shop more, which is a reminder that a good chunk of the market was pulling back rather than piling in, so a flat result against last year is not automatically a failure.

Worth tracking alongside total revenue is how many of your Black Friday customers were genuinely new to your business, since that is the number that tells you whether the campaign grew your customer base or simply moved existing demand earlier in the calendar. Worth watching too is what happens in December and January, whether the new customers you won come back, and whether your regular, full-price customers kept buying at their usual rate or waited for the next markdown. A plan built with a clear strategy behind it, in the way our guide to what a marketing strategy is sets out, gives you the framework to judge the day against more than the one-off number on the till.

A business owner reviewing how their Black Friday campaign performed
Liam Fisher, Co-founder of Starlight Tech

WRITTEN BY

Liam Fisher

Co-founder, Starlight Tech

Liam Fisher is co-founder of Starlight Tech, with his wife Anna Fisher, and the creator of Compass. He has spent 25 years leading marketing for design-led technology and creative brands, from challenger software to global entertainment names, and built Compass to put that expertise in the hands of small businesses running their own marketing.

How Compass Helps

Compass is built for small businesses running their own marketing, and planning a Black Friday that grows the business rather than draining it is exactly the kind of decision it is built to support. It learns your business, researches your market and your usual customer, and builds you a marketing strategy grounded in real marketing science, helping you decide what to discount, who to reach with it, and how to keep the offer honest under UK pricing rules. It turns that thinking into a short daily plan in plain English in the weeks before the day, and explains the reasoning behind each recommendation so you build the judgement to make these calls yourself next year. You make the decisions while Compass does the research and the recommending. Try Compass today by claiming a free 90 day growth plan for your business.

Get Started Free

Compass illustration for Black Friday Marketing Without the Race to the Bottom

FAQs

A small business does Black Friday well by starting preparation months ahead, choosing one clear and honest discount rather than a confusing stack of offers, and spending part of its effort reaching people who have never bought from it rather than only re-selling to existing customers at a lower price. The strongest results come from treating the day as one moment inside a wider plan, not as a single desperate attempt to match whatever a bigger competitor is offering.
It can be, provided the business treats the day as a chance to win genuinely new customers rather than simply giving existing ones a lower price on a sale that would have happened anyway. UK shoppers continue to spend meaningfully around Black Friday, with research from Barclays and Nationwide both pointing to strong activity on the day itself, but a discount that only pulls forward demand you already had is not real growth, it is margin given away for nothing.
Offer a discount you can clearly explain in one sentence and that reflects a genuine reduction against a price you charged, rather than the deepest percentage you can survive. A single, honest saving on a well-chosen product, backed by a reasonable "was" price under UK reference pricing rules, tends to build more trust and more repeat business than a maze of overlapping percentages that leave a shopper unsure what they are saving.
Showing a "was" price against a "now" price is legal in the UK provided the comparison is genuine and not misleading. UK guidance on reference pricing sets out what counts as a fair comparison, and trading standards guidance specifically warns against stacking repeated markdowns, such as showing "was £150, was £99, now half price £75," where the later claim does not represent a bigger saving than the one before it. Keep any reference price honest and avoid layering discount claims on top of each other for effect.
Keep the discount modest enough that it does not teach your regular customers to wait for a sale before buying, and put real effort into reaching new customers rather than only re-selling to people already on your list. Marketing science shows that brands grow by gaining new buyers rather than by repeatedly discounting to existing ones, so a Black Friday plan built around genuine reach, honest pricing, and proper preparation protects both your margin and how your brand is seen for the rest of the year.