SOFTWARE & TECH

How to Do a DIY SEO Audit for Your Website

8 Minute Read

An SEO audit is a structured check of your website's technical health, its content and its local presence, done to find out why it is or is not showing up in search and in the AI answers that increasingly stand in front of it. You run one yourself by working through four layers in order, crawlability, page experience, content, and local presence, fixing each before you judge the next. I have run these audits on Starlight Tech's own site and talked through them with small business owners who assumed an audit meant an agency and an invoice. It does not. This guide covers what an SEO audit checks, the order that gets you a real result rather than a wasted weekend, and a simple way to run one yourself this afternoon.

A small business owner reviewing their website during a quiet moment in the shop

What Is an SEO Audit, and Why Does a Small Business Need One?

An SEO audit is a diagnostic. You are not writing new pages or buying anything, you are working through your existing website and asking a blunt question at each layer: is anything here stopping a search engine, or increasingly an AI tool, from finding, understanding and trusting this page. Most small businesses never run one. They write content, they wait, and when the traffic does not arrive they assume the writing was not good enough. Often the writing is fine and something underneath it is broken, a page search engines cannot reach, a site that loads too slowly on a phone, a Google Business Profile nobody has touched in a long while. An audit finds the actual blockage instead of guessing at it, and it is one of the cheapest marketing activities a small business can run, because the cost is your time and the fixes compound for years rather than fading once a campaign ends.

A shop owner noting down issues found while reviewing their website

Start With Crawlability, Because Nothing Else Matters Until Search Engines Can See You

Run your audit in the wrong order and you will spend time polishing content that nobody, human or machine, will ever see. Start at the bottom layer. Can a search engine or an AI crawler reach your pages. Check your robots.txt file, the small text file that tells crawlers what they are allowed to look at, and confirm it is not blocking the pages that bring in business. Search Engine Land puts this as plainly as it can be put: if robots.txt is blocking your money pages, nothing else matters, and fixing crawlability has to come first. As an illustration, picture a fictional plumbing firm called Riverside Drainage, whose booking page sat outside Google's index because of a single misplaced line in its robots.txt file, invisible to search however carefully the page itself was written.

This is physical availability in the language of marketing science, Byron Sharp's term for how easily a customer can find and buy from you. A brand with strong positioning and no distribution does not grow, and a website with strong content and no crawlability does not either. Your audit's first job is making sure the door is open before you worry about the window display.

A tradesperson checking whether online bookings are coming through

Check Your Core Web Vitals and Page Experience

Once a crawler can reach your pages, check whether it likes what it finds when they load. Core Web Vitals measure how fast your pages load, how quickly they respond to a tap, and how much the layout shifts around while loading, the kind of thing that makes someone close your site before they have read a word. Core Web Vitals sit inside Google's ranking systems, while other elements of page experience mostly affect how a page feels rather than where it ranks, according to RivuletIQ's 2026 review of the metric, which is worth knowing before you spend a weekend polishing something that makes a page nicer without moving your position. Run your homepage and your most important pages through a free testing tool, note anything flagged as poor, and fix the worst offender first, usually an oversized image or a font that loads in a way that shifts the whole page. Treat this as maintenance rather than a one-off, because a plugin update or a new banner image can undo the fix within weeks.

A customer waiting for a slow website to load

Audit Your Content Against What People Are Asking

With the technical layer sound, move up to the content itself. Read your most important pages as if you were the customer who had never heard of you, and check whether each one answers a real question in the opening lines rather than working up to it after paragraphs of throat-clearing. Buyers arrive at different stages of readiness. Some have never heard of the problem your business solves, some know the problem well and are comparing a shortlist, and your content needs to speak to whichever stage brings people to that page rather than the stage you wish they were at. A page written for someone who already knows your brand and is weighing up price will do little for the reader who does not yet know a solution like yours exists, and a page written to explain the basics will bore the reader who is ready to book. Check your title tags and headings too, since these are the first thing both a search engine and a human scanning a results page read, and a vague heading like "Our Services" tells neither of them anything useful. Our deeper guide to on-page SEO walks through title tags, headings and internal linking if this section raises more questions than it answers.

An owner reading their website as a customer would see it

Audit Your Local Listings and Reviews

If your customers find you by searching for a trade or a town rather than your business name, your audit has to leave the website and check your local presence. Open your Google Business Profile and confirm the address, hours and category are current, because a profile that says you close at five when you close at six costs you a booking nobody tells you about. Then look at your review count. BrightLocal's 2026 research into small business marketing found that 47 percent of small businesses have fewer than 20 reviews, and 47 percent of consumers say that is not enough to trust a business. If your number sits under that, the fix is a standing habit of asking every satisfied customer on the day the job is done, repeated regularly rather than attempted once. Check too that your name, address and phone number match exactly across every directory you appear in, since a mismatch between your website and an old directory listing is the kind of small inconsistency that erodes the trust search engines place in your facts. Our guide to local SEO covers the full set of local ranking signals if this is the layer where you are weakest.

A cafe owner at the point of service where a review request happens

Why Your Audit Has to Account for AI Answers Now

A few years ago an SEO audit stopped at the search results page. It cannot stop there any more, because a growing share of the people searching for what you do never reach a results page at all, they read a written answer and move on. Pew Research Center's analysis of real search sessions found that users who encountered an AI summary clicked a traditional search result in only 8 percent of visits, against 15 percent when no summary appeared, and the same research found that a session was more likely to end there and then when an AI Overview was present, concluding 26 percent of the time against 16 percent without one. Your audit now needs a step the old version never had. Ask ChatGPT, Gemini and Google's AI Overview the questions your customers would type, and note whether your business gets named, described correctly, and linked, or whether it is missing while a competitor gets the mention instead. The fixes overlap heavily with the content and local checks above, clear answers, consistent facts, genuine reviews, because the signals that earn a ranking are largely the signals that earn a citation. Our guide to answer engine optimisation goes deeper on winning that mention on purpose rather than leaving it to chance.

A customer asking an AI assistant which local business to choose

Get the Order Right, or the Fixes Will Not Show Results

The order you work through these layers in changes what you see happen. Search Engine Land's account of a real technical overhaul is a useful warning here: fixing a site's technical SEO issues improved crawling and indexing, but rankings, traffic and visibility did not move until metadata updates were made afterwards. Read that as encouragement to keep going through every layer, and as a reminder that each layer needs time to show its effect before you judge whether the next one worked. Fix crawlability and give it time for re-indexing to catch up. Fix Core Web Vitals and give the ranking systems a cycle to notice. Move to content and metadata next, where most of the visible movement in rankings tends to show up, and finish with local and AI presence, which often improves fastest because reviews and listings update close to real time. Fixing everything in one chaotic afternoon and checking your rankings the next morning is how people conclude an audit did not work when it was simply too soon to tell.

Two colleagues working through an audit checklist in order

A Simple DIY SEO Audit You Can Run This Afternoon

Put the layers above into a single working session and this is roughly how it runs.

  1. Check crawlability first. Look at your robots.txt file and your XML sitemap, and confirm your most important pages are not blocked.
  2. Test your Core Web Vitals. Run your homepage and top pages through a free testing tool and fix the worst-flagged issue.
  3. Read your top pages as a stranger. Check whether each answers the real question in the opening lines and matches what a visitor needs at that stage.
  4. Tidy your title tags and headings. Make each one specific enough that a person scanning a results page knows exactly what it is for.
  5. Audit your local listings. Confirm your Google Business Profile is current and your name, address and phone number match everywhere you are listed.
  6. Ask the AI tools about yourself. Type the questions your customers would ask into ChatGPT or Google's AI Overview and note what comes back.

Work through the list in that order, give each fix time before judging it, and keep returning to the whole audit on a regular rhythm, since a website drifts out of condition the moment nobody checks on it.

An owner running through their own SEO audit step by step
Liam Fisher, Co-founder of Starlight Tech

WRITTEN BY

Liam Fisher

Co-founder, Starlight Tech

Liam Fisher is co-founder of Starlight Tech, with his wife Anna Fisher, and the creator of Compass. He has spent 25 years leading marketing for design-led technology and creative brands, from challenger software to global entertainment names, and built Compass to put that expertise in the hands of small businesses running their own marketing.

How Compass Helps

Compass is built for small businesses running their own marketing, and a clear SEO audit is part of the research it already does for you. It studies your website, your Google Business Profile and how your business shows up in AI answers, then builds you a marketing strategy that puts the fixes in the order that works, crawlability first, then page experience, then content, then local and AI presence. It turns the findings into a short daily plan in plain English, the sitemap check, the review request, the title tag rewrite, and explains the reasoning behind each step so you build the judgement to run your own audits over time. You make the decisions while Compass does the research and the recommending. Try Compass today by claiming a free 90 day growth plan for your business.

Get Started Free

Compass illustration for How to Do a DIY SEO Audit for Your Website

FAQs

Work through four layers in order. Check crawlability first, confirming your robots.txt file and sitemap are not blocking your important pages. Then check Core Web Vitals and page experience with a free testing tool. Move up to your content, checking that your top pages answer real questions in the opening lines for the stage of reader who arrives there. Then audit your local listings, your Google Business Profile details and your review count, and finish by asking AI tools like ChatGPT and Google's AI Overview the questions your customers would ask, to see whether your business gets mentioned.
A full SEO audit checks four layers: crawlability, whether search engines and AI crawlers can reach your pages; page experience, including Core Web Vitals such as loading speed and layout stability; content, whether your pages answer real customer questions clearly; and local presence, your Google Business Profile, your reviews, and whether your business name, address and phone number match across every directory you appear in.
Run a full audit whenever you make a significant change to your site, notice your traffic drifting, or have not checked in a while, then keep revisiting it on a regular rhythm rather than once and never again. A website is not a finished thing. Plugins update, pages get added, and small technical issues creep back in, so an audit works best as a repeated habit rather than a single event.
No. The checks in a basic SEO audit, crawlability, Core Web Vitals, content clarity and local listing accuracy, can all be done with free tools and an honest read of your own website. An agency can go deeper on complex technical issues or large sites, but a small business with a handful of pages can run a genuinely useful audit itself in an afternoon.
Because a growing share of searches never reach a traditional results page. Research into real search sessions found that users who encountered an AI summary clicked a traditional search result in only 8 percent of visits, against 15 percent when no summary appeared, and that sessions concluded without a click 26 percent of the time with an AI Overview present against 16 percent without one, according to Pew Research Center's findings reported by The Register. An audit that only checks traditional rankings misses an increasingly large part of how customers find a business.